Annual Edition 1961 American ModelerTable of Contents
Some things never grow old. These pages from vintage modeling magazines like American Aircraft Modeler, American Modeler, Air Trails, Flying Aces, Flying Models, Model Airplane News, & Young Men captured the era. I will be glad to scan articles for you. All copyrights are hereby acknowledged.
This article was scanned from the 1961 American Modeler Annual edition. It has been out of print for decades, and is difficult to access unless you are fortunate enough to buy one off of e-Bay. Hopefully the original authors won't mind, but if they do, I will remove it.
Airfoil plotting goes back to the NACA days of white shirts, neck ties, thick-rimmed glasses, and slide rules. Drawing boards, straight edges, and French curves had not yet been replaced by software on every engineer's personal computer. Consider this a window for a look back in history.
Larry Conover, 1960 World Champion
F.A.I. Free Flighter in an exclusive report reveal
How to make it fly like a bird? This was the pressing question for aerial experimenters of long ago. And still is for model designers of today!
In ancient times they said, "Make the wing liken to a bird."
But it seemed that any direct copies of bird sections flew no better than those experiments done via gliding a dead stuffed bird, wings braced out stiff.
Actually they were on the right track. Just lacked a few of the other essentials needed for man to fly.
Lawrence H. Conover of Cedar Rapids, Iowa, and member of America's 1960 F.A.I. Power Championships free flight team launches his entry at Cranfield, England, in finals. Along with 4 other contenders Larry was crowned as "joint" competition champ.
But as the wind picked up, or the heat of the sun warmed valleys and hillsides, the birds became unbelievably efficient. "f.hey soared upward on wings apparently locked out stiff. In effortless wheeling circles, became -pin points against the clouds.
This was too much for man to solve, at least for the moment.
So the practical beginners stretched cloth over one side of a supporting framework. (Like a kite.)
Lilienthal soon discovered that a certain amount of curvature gave better results than a flat surface.
The Wright brothers found that Lilienthal's measurements of "lift and drift" for certain airfoil curvatures were incorrect. In the first wind tunnel they worked out the proper sections for their "Flyers."
Later, both sides of the wing were covered so the spars wouldn't stick out. . And when faired in properly, it produced a pleasantly streamlined shape.
Between 1912 and 1920 most wing sections were designed around spars and structures. Eyeballed smooth with a French curve.
M. Joukowsky, during the First World War. derived his airfoil shapes mathematically. These were systematically tested at Goettingen. Modifications of these sections bear the name of Goettingen.
Well, modern aerodynamicists still don't know all the secrets of bird flight. But they have discovered a few things about stiff wings.
One of the most important facts to the model designer is that he must work in a Reynolds Number range below freezing. RN below 100,000. There are few measurements of full-scale wing sections that fall in this range. In fact, most of them are over ten times higher!
For that reason very few full-scale measurements give a true picture of what is going on in the model airfoil range. In addition, there is quite some difference between artificial wind tunnel air and the free air the birds fly in.
Therefore you must rely on proven sections, or those developed especially for model aircraft. The following thirty-three airfoils will give you something to fit any occasion.
For those who are not completely familiar with the method of plotting a section, I will show you briefly one way to do it.
Refer to the page on Airfoil Plotting. A full size scale is drawn for you. Cut it out and glue lightly to a piece of hard sheet balsa, 1/16 x 1/2 x 11 inches.
STEP ONE: Note that the chord length is 100%. All measurements of your drawing will be based on IT.
The graduated part of the scale is ten inches long. Place the "P" end of it at the leading edge "0" point, scale parallel with datum line. Using this point as a pivot. raise the scale until the 100 mark lines up with all extension' of the trailing edge chord mark. Continue as directed.
STRICKLY FOR THE BIRDS! That's how L.C. describes these two sections.
Rather interesting airfoils; looks like 'boids' have French curves
STEP THREE: Now comes the fun.
If you don't know how to multiply on a slide rule, this is the time to ask an engineer friend, or your math teacher. Or even the clerk at the drafting-supplies store. He can teach you in ten minutes - on a two dollar slide rule - enough to save you hours of tedious long multiplication.
However, if you choose an even chord length you can do much of the work in your head.
Now make up a data sheet with only the stations marked in. You must fill in the upper and lower values from calculations of the ordinate multiplied by the chord length.
An example for station 70 shows the product of an eight inch chord times the upper ordinate 6.2 equals 49.6 (hundredths of an inch). This is very close to 50 hundredths of an inch, which is, of course, one half inch.
In practice it is very doubtful that you could mark off to closer than one hundredth of an inch. So generally you can round off the figure following the decimal point.
Don't let the placement of decimal points worry you too much. When you mark the dots for the airfoil curve, you will quickly see what range you should be in.
Keep your pencil sharp, preferably a 6H drawing pencil. It may help you to encircle each plotted point as you transfer the calculated number from the data sheet onto the curve.
You'll find it's fun to get the hang of estimating distances down to a hundredth of an inch with only your pencil point. Your eye has amazing accuracy, when trained just a little.
Now how about those airfoils?
You will-soon find that many of these sections are by Georges Benedek. He has done outstanding experimental model research at the Hungarian Modeling Institute. His airfoils are the latest development in this field, and the most popular in Europe, Many of the record holding models use Benedek sections.
B-6356-b. A popular Nordic and Wakefield section for more than ten years.
B-6407-e. A Benedek modification of an airfoil by Erich Jedelsky, having a long flapped trailing edge. External rib bracing (underside) on thin plywood, or very high quality C stock balsa sheet, are requirements for this type of construction.
B-6456-f. Used on some of the best Hungarian A-2 models.
B-6556-b. A variation of the popular 8556. A bit sensitive in pitch.
B-7457-d-2. A modification of the thin flapped T.E., which allows more internal structural support.
B-8405-b. A general purpose section.
B-8556-b. Used on first Rumanian A-2 . model to exceed 900 seconds total time.
MVA-439. Average performance is about 2: 30 in calm air. Has good turbulent weather (thermal) performance.
MMVA-123. As reviewed by Dr. Lippisch, this section has a very high lift-drag ratio of 64 to 1. But the CIL max (coefficient of lift) is rather low. This however makes it an ideal section for Jetex models, which must have very low drag.
E.J.-75. A basic type of flapped T.E. airfoil developed by Mr. Jedelsky.
NACA-6306. A 6% section similar to the MVA 123. Maximum camber further forward. (At 30%)
EIFFEL-400. Very popular among all modelers for some twenty years. Best suited to rubber models.
NACA-6409. Another very popular section, usually associated with power models. A fast efficient airfoil for rubber jobs.
NACA-6412. A good standard section for models operating under slow speed or high lift conditions.
RAF-32. A well liked British section for large rubber models or gas. Has disadvantage of a rather large center of pressure travel. But this has not affected its popularity.
MVA-173. A thin highly cambered section with good duration potential, if you can handle the stability problems.
MVA-359. A calm air average performance of 2:30 on A-2 glider. Good in turbulent air.
CCHEESMAN-810. Mr. Cheesman designates this a laminar flow section. Briton John Barker found its performance even better than the NACA-6409. That's right good!
B-7406-f. Benedek used this airfoil on the first Hungarian Wakefield to make a consistent five minute average under the old rules.
BB-8306-b. Claimed to be good stable section with all 'round performance. Note that a deep undercamber usually results in sensitivity in pitch axis.
BB-8356-b. Benedek set a record by being first Hungarian to make a 900 second total under the
80 gram motor
B-6405-b. Airfoil used on Benedek's 1958 5th place winner at Cranfield World Championships. Model showed excellent "prop-hanging" stability in very gusty weather.
G-610-B. Carl Goldberg's famous wing section used on the Zipper and Sailplane, etc. A very good airfoil.
MVA-301. Perhaps the best liked section from MVA. It gives excellent performance in all ranges above a five inch chord. Note that I have drawn an almost pointed entry on the L.E.
NACA-6309. Similar to the 6409 but with high point further forward.
LLUCKY LINDY. Standard section for all my FAI power models. Low drag. Has a better glide than the shape would indicate. Must have turbulators for pitch stability.
CLARK-Y. Perhaps the best known airfoil in the world. It was developed by Col. V. E. Clark in 1922. Its performance is not spectacular in anyone field, but it's a good all-rounder.
NACA-4309. A section for faster models. Has small center of pressure movement, which aids pitch stability.
B-8356-b. Designed originally for Wakefield and Nordic, this section shows good potential for a low-rate-of sink power model.
B-8353-b-2. Designed specifically for the heavy weight FAI Power rules. A high speed section.
B-9304-b. Another special airfoil for latest F AI Power rules.
2242-G. A Goettingen high 11ft section recommended by Dr. Lippisch for Clipper Cargo, or any type requiring very high lift values. Notice the pointed leading edge, similar to some bird wings. He emphasizes that the under surface of the wing must be very . smooth on sections of this type.
GOElTINGEN-602. A good medium speed, low drag section.
You now have the basis for a scientific approach to model airfoil selection. And you have the. method for reproducing any desired section, in any size.
AMERICAN MODELER ANNUAL 1961
Airfoil Plotting Method
Wing Sections for Rubber Models
Wing Sections for Power Models
Wings Sections for Nordic Gliders
Posted January 17, 2013