April 1957 American ModelerTable of Contents
Some things never grow old. These pages from vintage modeling magazines like American Aircraft Modeler, American Modeler, Air Trails, Flying Aces, Flying Models, Model Airplane News, & Young Men captured the era. I will be glad to scan articles for you. All copyrights are hereby acknowledged.
Peter Bowers first became know to me because of his Fly Baby homebuilt airplane. It won the Experimental Aircraft Association (EAA) design contest in 1962. Back in the middle and late 1970s, I was taking flying lessons and dreaming big about building my own aerobatic biplane. Being an avid woodworker, the Fly Baby appealed to me because it was constructed entirely of wood, except for a few critical metal fittings. My plan was to build the biplane version of the Fly Baby. Like so many other things, the aeroplane never got built. Peter Bowers was not only an aeronautical engineer and airplane designer but also an aviation historian and model airplane enthusiast. This article from a 1957 edition of American Modeler is an example of his endeavors.
By Peter M. Bowers
Author Bowers flys steel-tube replica of 1912 Curtiss built in '47 by Waller Bullock (now owned by Ed Weeks. Des Moines).
Pete inspects old Jenny.
Note condition of Heath Parasol when he acquired it along with spare Szekeley.
Not all antique hunters who poke around in old attics and barns are looking for Duncan Phyfe furniture or Paul Revere silver. Some, thanks to the recent surge of interest in vintage aircraft, are snooping for an old Jenny, or at least a Heath Parasol.
This is not just a random undertaking on the part of a few individuals. Interest in old airplanes is worldwide, and is encouraged by several formal organizations. Oldest is the Vintage Airplane Association in England; best-known here is the Antique Airplane Association, formed several years ago by Robert L. Taylor, with headquarters at 429 North Market Street, Ottumwa, Iowa.
As the organization grew rapidly, it was soon issuing a monthly publication on slick paper to replace an original mimeographed bulletin that had kept the members posted.
In 1955, the AAA polled its membership to determine just what age should qualify an airplane as an antique. The response was overwhelmingly in favor of a calendar age of twenty-five years, which is short by antique furniture standards but positively venerable when considering that aviation itself is barely fifty years old.
This arbitrary line of demarcation brings up problems of its own, as in the case of one basic airplane design built over a period of years divided by the line. A Fleet Model 2, built in 1929, qualifies as a genuine antique while a near-duplicate Model 16, built in Canada early in WW-II, does not. Actually, it is the configuration of the airplane, rather than its actual year of manufacture, that appeals to the collector and establishes the antique classification. No one would hesitate to call any of the wire-braced Aeronca C-3's built between 1931 and 1936 an antique, but they would think twice before calling a Douglas DC-3 an antique even though that model was introduced late in 1935.
Antique airplanes fall into two general classes-those that are rebuilt and flown by their owners strictly as a hobby or for sentimental reasons, and those that are workhorses doing a job that more modem equipment cannot do as well. In the first class will be found the purely sporting models such as the Heath Parasol and Pietenpol, other home-builts, and the smaller training and personal types like the Fleet and the Taylor Cub. A few World War I and earlier designs are included.
The second class is made up mainly of ships that still have relatively high commercial value, or that are too heavy and expensive for the average private owner to maintain, and includes most of the Travel Air biplanes, still widely used as sprayers, the Ford Trimotors, for which a suitable replacement has yet to be built, and most of the four-to-six-place cabin monoplanes of the late twenties and early thirties that are still well suited to mountain flying and other short-field work. These models are too valuable to be kept off to one side as a hobby even if their owners could afford to do so.
Before dealing with the question of where these old airplanes come from, mention should be made of two places where they do NOT come from, both of which are dead ends enviously eyed by the old airplane fans. Most of the real old timers are in museums, sometimes on display but more often in storage due to lack of suitable space, and fortunate indeed is the collector who has been able to obtain one from this source by purchase or trade.
Two collectors, Frank Tallman of Glenview, Illinois, and Cole Palen of Poughkeepsie, New York, managed to score phenomenal successes in this direction by buying out private museum collections. Tallman bought four of the six WW-I types remaining in the J. B. Jarrett Museum of World War History, and Palen obtained several World War I types and a prewar I Bleriot that used to be in the Aviation Museum at Roosevelt Field, Long Island. These are exceptional cases, however, and the museums were private, rather than public, institutions.
1931 Razorback Aeronca C-3 owned by P. B. 1934-36 Aeroncas with altered fuselage and cabin also called C-3s.
Thomas-Morse S-4C owned by Paul Kotze still uses the tricky rotary engine which went out of production at end of WW-I.
Pietenpol "Air Camper" powered by converted Model "A" Ford engine; owned by Allen Rudolph, Woodland, Wisconsin.
Oldest production sportplane in U. S. is 1919 Ace powered by 40-hp water-cooled Ace engine. Rebuilt by Lorill Lowrey.
Single seat 1930 Buhl Bull Pup with 45 hp Szekeley engine. Several modified with new motor, cut-down Luscombe panels.
Ordinarily, one would think that the place to start looking for old airplanes would be around an airport, but such is not the case. Of course, there are some old relics hanging in the rafters or stuffed in the corner of the shop, but most of the old timers that can be found at an active airport are owned by people who want to keep them, Storage space at an airport comes high, and is not likely to be occupied by some forgotten hulk that the owner doesn't want.
Logical place to look for a long-stored airplane is in a place where it is out of the way and where the space does not cost the owner or his heirs anything. Old barns in rural areas where farmers used to fly their own planes back in the license-free days provide good hunting, while logical places to look in cities are in the rafters of garages and machine shops. Owners or employees of such places would have had better-than-average qualifications for building or restoring airplanes as a hobby. The author recently obtained a 1930 Pietenpol Air Camper that had been stored in a machine shop since 1937.
Other sources of old aircraft, especially military models, are schools, from high school through college, that have, or used to have, aeronautical courses. In the years between World Wars, and again after WW-II, the government gave many surplus aircraft to such organizations for classroom use. Many were broken down into parts, or otherwise cut up, but some were left intact.
Major difficulty involved in obtaining one of these types when it is found is the fact that most of the government gifts had a string tied to them - the school was prohibited from selling them or using them for other than educational purposes. There have been numerous cases in recent years where schools have junked their older relics after obtaining more modern replacements merely because they could do nothing else with them.
A glider pilot friend, Ken Hovik, visited a home in Everett, Washington, one day to hang some venetian blinds. He noticed a picture of an old glider on the wall, and arranged to come back on his own time to talk to the owner, since he was interested in such things. During the course of the ensuing conversation, the former glider owner mentioned the presence of the old Pietenpol in a nearby machine shop. Ken took a look at it, found that it was available, and told the author, who contacted the trustees of the late owner's estate and arranged a purchase.
In a way, this is a typical case, where several people interested in old airplanes had driven within a block of this plane for years without realizing that it was there. The really lucky part is that the plane was "Found" just in time, for the contents of the shop were being disposed of at the time, and the wooden airframe was slated for the bonfire.
People who are searching for a specific type are seldom so lucky, but a few succeed after phenomenal demonstrations of patience. The more specific the collector's desired plane, the more frustrating his search can become. The most desirable, and of course the hardest to find, are genuine World War I types. There are roughly one hundred of them in the hands of museums or private owners today, and it is conservatively estimated that as many more are still hiding out in barns and basements, unknown to the collectors and virtually forgotten by their owners or their surviving families.
This is one of the great tragedies of antique airplane hunting. Many of the non-aviation people who do come across an old airplane think that it is of no use to anyone, and destroy it as a worthless piece of junk. Such was the case with a Spad in eastern Washington. An old farmer who had owned it had refused to sell it to the few aeronautical people that knew he had it stored in the barn. It had been his old ship, and he was sentimentally attached to it. The farmer died, and when his family took over the farm they found that the old bundle of sticks was only in the way, and burned it. This is a typical situation.
1930 Heath Parasol owned by Frank Falejezyc, Lakewood. N.Y. Changes include 37 hp Continental.
Sopwith Camel owned by Frank Tallman rebuilt from museum piece soon to be joined by restored German Pfalz D-XDIII.
This 22' home-built first flew in 1930, was rebuilt in '54 as Hobart Sorrell Special. Cruises at 90 mph with 65 hp Continental.
Fleet "2" owned by Paul Ollembury, Milwaukee, typical of breed between '29 and '41. This is rare one with unmodified tail.
One of two Hisso Standards used by Paul Mantz in "Spirit of St. Louis" movie. In WW-I·used Hall-Scott engines.
The actual running down of an old airplane usually involves a lot of leg work in following up third and fourth-hand tips. Some friend of the collector knows someone else who used to work with a guy who told him that so-and-so's uncle's neighbor had an old airplane in his barn.
Most frustrating part of this game lies in trying to find out just what kind of an airplane is involved. Most people are unable to describe an airplane beyond the point of saying how many wings it has, and to others more informed any old biplane is a "Jenny." The term "Old Airplane" can easily apply to a 1940 Cub or to a real antique, and the collector has to answer the sixty-four dollar question of whether or not the thing is worth the effort of running it down.
The time element is extremely flexible in such cases, too, especially in the minds of people who are not themselves interested in the subject. Some old farmer may be quite sure that he saw a plane in a friend's barn over in the next county just a couple of years ago, but a follow-up often reveals that he actually saw it ten or twelve years before. All too often, the collector finds that there was a plane in the place described, but that it had been destroyed a short time before. As a result, serious collectors have learned not to put off following up a rumor, no matter how faint, even until next week.
When the antique hunter does locate an old airplane, his problems are only beginning. First, there is the matter of obtaining it. This can range from the extreme of being given it in return for hauling it away to writing a check for an amount exceeding that for which a complete replica could be built, or even patiently waiting for an obdurate owner to die.
Best example of the first case is that of Jim Mathiesen, a collector of Berkeley, California, who also owns a Fokker D-VII, a Boeing FB-5 fighter, and a Thomas-Morse S-4. He happened to know where a 1911 Bleriot had been stored since 1919. He thought that this would make an interesting exhibit at an airport Open House commemorating the Fiftieth Anniversary of Flight, so he asked the warehouse owner if he could borrow the plane. The owner told him that he could - under one condition. Knowing what such a ship was worth, and expecting to be stuck for a lot of insurance, Jim asked what the condition was.
"That you get the - - - - -thing out of here and don't bring it back!"
Others are not so fortunate, and there is no way of setting a price on planes or parts. A set of Jenny wings may have an asking price of five dollars a panel or five thousand dollars a set, depending somewhat on condition and other variables, but mainly on who has them and who wants them, and for what.
Once the collector has title to his antique, he is faced with the problem of restoring it. In practically all cases, the airplane was in pretty bad shape when it was found, and structural deterioration makes it necessary to replace many basic components. The fact that most old timers were just pushed off to one corner of the damp barn without preservative measures of any kind being taken only hastened the harm done by humidity, rain, livestock, and the accumulation of old junk piled on it through the years. Because of this, many of the old timers flying today are antiques in configuration only, practically all of their basic structure having been replaced with modern materials.
Replacing structural components is not a special problem - new parts can generally be built from standard materials by conventional methods. Accessories, especially engines, propellers, and wheels, are another matter. In many cases, the engines of old airplanes have been removed and used for other purposes, as have the wheels. Replacement parts for the old engines are hard to obtain, and often have to be made by hand. Old wheels are often useless because the odd-size old clincher tires are no longer made. Many owners of antiques are forced to use modern powerplants in their planes, which many are glad to do in the interest of reliability and safety at the expense of a slight loss of authenticity.
Cost of restoration is a very variable item, depending mainly on the circumstances of the builder, who may have a good stock of the material needed instead of having to buy every item. Then too, he may do his own work or have to hire it done. The cost of materials alone just for covering an average-size biplane can run to about $500, and rebuilding an old engine that requires replacement parts to be hand made can cost much more.
Actual worth of the old airplane when finally restored is not always proportional to the work involved, nor does age alone add any particular value, as some people who have spent six or eight hundred dollars rebuilding 1935 Cubs have found out.
Most "elephant ear" Travel Air biplanes still flying are dusters or sprayers with modern engines.
Trimotor of Johnson Flying Service typical of ten "Tin Goose" Fords still paying way via spraying, smoke-jump, transport jobs.
Sammy Mason revived wing-walking act in 1946 with modified Ranger-engined Jenny. Plane now has 220 hp radial.
Waco 10 (later GXE) typical of many bipes built as late as '29 to take surplus WWI Curtiss OX-5 90 hp engine.
1928 Curtiss Robin modernized with WWI surplus 220 hp Lycoming engine replacing OX-5. Was owned by Walter Wright.
Recent experience indicates that Fleet biplanes in good condition are fairly well stabilized between $700 and $1,000 even though one could not be overhauled and recovered at that price today. Aeronca C-3's, on the other hand, have sold licensed for as little as $200 five years ago, but are now so well thought of as antiques that the price has climbed to the vicinity of $450 for airworthy models with old fabric and to $600 or more for rebuilds.
One specialized problem that must be faced by all airplane owners, actual and potential, is that of storage and working space. Many who have an opportunity to buy an interesting ship are forced to pass it up because they have no place to keep it. Many antiques in poor condition have been passed from hand to hand without ever being worked on merely because of the lack of suitable facilities. On the other hand, some people with plenty of space available sometimes buy old ships that they are not particularly interested in merely because they are old enough to be of interest to someone, and therefore of some value as trading material if nothing else.
As in the antique furniture game, there are fake airplanes as well as fake Queen Anne chairs, but the owners of the replica aircraft are not held in contempt nor do they try to pass off their reproductions as the real thing. Configuration is the important thing, and the copy can usually be expected to have the handling characteristics of the original, which is not available.
A number of replicas have been built since WW-II, some of which are as accurate in structure as it is possible to make them while others have been completely redesigned and modernized. Two Bleriots, authentic except for powerplant, have been built for recent commemorative flights across the English Channel, and a Sopwith Pup, complete with rotary engine, is being built from original factory blueprints in Canada. Walter Bullock, a Northwest Airlines pilot who used to own a 1912 Curtiss before World War I, built an aerodynamically-similar replica in 1947. He obtained the full satisfaction of flying that type of airplane while enjoying the peace of mind that went with a modern engine and steel tube construction.
Jack MacRae, of Hempstead. L. I., has taken a different course entirely, and completey redesigned the Driggs Dart of 1926 into the "Super Dart." which is regarded by pilots and CAA alike as a 1953 airplane. Collectors are divided in the matter of flying old ships - some will put up with any amount of balkiness and unreliability to keep the old timer "pure" while others stress reliability above all else. For example, two Pietenpols were seen at the 1955 Fly-In of the Experimental Aircraft Association; one with the original water-cooled Model A Ford engine and the other with a modern air-cooled 65 HP Lycoming engine under a modern lightplane cowling.
Entirely aside from the enjoyment that one gets from rebuilding an old airplane, or flying in one of the few remaining open-cockpit biplanes, two owners of the antiques derive immense satisfaction from the comment that their old-timers stir up when they arrive at public airports. The author has obtained very mixed reactions with his 1931 Razorback model Aeronca C-3. Old pilots who gather around it pat it lovingly, and tell of how they soloed on that model, or how much time they have in it, but the younger generation looks it over skeptically and wonders out loud "did you build it yourself, Mister?"
As a result of the current interest in airplanes of World War I vintage, a listing of all the presently-known World War I types in the country is presented on pg. 58-59 of this issue, with each individual airplane identified as to owner or location, and condition. The listing could never be completely accurate, in that many privately-owned aircraft are constantly changing hands, while others are rumors that have not been fully confirmed. The distribution of museum-owned planes can be expected to remain stable.
Posted June 21, 2014